Switch back to WCC classic look

WorkCompCentral – Workers' Compensation Education, Courses, News and Information

Call or email us anytime
(805) 484-0333
Search Guide
Today is Saturday, December 16, 2017 -


Christmas: S.C. Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Injured Worker

  • State: South Carolina

The South Carolina Supreme Court recently ruled that a retail employee was entitled to a permanent and total disability (PTD) award despite being able to return to work at his old position.

Gary Christmas

Gary Christmas

Under South Carolina workers’ compensation statutes, there are two ways an injured employee may be entitled to collect benefits for total disability.

Under South Carolina Code Section 42-9-10, he can be entitled to a PTD award if he has a complete "incapacity for work." Under Section 42-9-30, an injured worker may be entitled to PTD if he has suffered the functional loss of use of at least 50% of the injured body part.


In September 2010, Henton Clemmons Jr. was working as a cashier at Lowe’s Home Improvement Center when he slipped and fell while assisting a customer. The fall severely injured his back. A neurological specialist determined that Clemmons had a herniated disc and needed immediate surgery.

The surgeon removed the disc and fused the C5 and C7 vertebrae, screwing a rod into Clemmons' spine. This surgery was followed by extensive physical rehabilitation. Despite these treatments, Clemmons still had difficulty walking and balancing, and continued to have pain in his back and neck.

Clemmons filed for workers’ compensation benefits, and Lowe’s admitted the claim. It agreed to pay temporary total disability (TTD) benefits until Clemmons reached maximum medical Improvement (MMI) or returned to his position.

In June 2011, his doctor concluded that Clemmons had reached MMI and determined a whole-person impairment rating of 25%, which converted to a 71% regional impairment to his spine.

The doctor also concluded that Clemmons could return his job, with specific permanent restriction. The employer agreed to these restrictions, and Clemmons went back to his cashier position.

One year later, the doctor reached the same MMI conclusion after a conducting a follow-up evaluation. The employer then requested a hearing in front of the commission to determine if any permanent disability benefits were owed to Clemmons. There were multiple evaluations by other medical professionals prior to the hearing and all concluded that Clemmons had suffered greater than 50% regional impairment to the back, with a more than 50% loss of back function.

The ruling

The commission ruled that Clemmons had not suffered PTD, since there was only a 48% loss of back function. They ruled that he was entitled only to permanent and partial disability (PPD). Clemmons filed an appeal, and the Court of Appeals affirmed the commission’s decision.

However, the Supreme Court disagreed. The justices found that under Section 42-9-30, Clemmons did indeed suffer a 50% loss of back function based on the medical evidence he presented.

The decision leaves employers plenty of room when it comes to rebutting the Section 42-9-30 presumption, although the outcome was very fact-specific. The outcome seemed to turn on the fact that Lowe’s did not offer any rebuttal evidence other than wage loss, turning the case in favor of Clemmons.

The court’s decision also leaves open the possibility of employers using medical opinion testimony from its own experts, lay witness testimony or deposing the worker's experts in order to put up robust cases that can meet the burden.

Gary Christmas is a partner with Howell & Christmas, a Charleston, South Carolina, law firm that represents workers’ compensation claimants.

No Comments

Log in to post a comment


Do not post libelous remarks. You are solely responsible for the postings you input. By posting here you agree to hold harmless and indemnify WorkCompCentral for any damages and actions your post may cause.

Featured Video

Upcoming Events

  • Jan 6, 2018

    2018 Liens, Costs and Med-Lega

    New for 2018 - learn all pertinent laws, skills and tools for lien issues starting January 2018. …

  • Jan 20, 2018

    2018 MCLE Super Saturday

    Overview: This program provides the six hours of “Special Requirement” training, within the …

  • Jan 22-23, 2018

    2018 Florida Comp Update

    The 2018 Florida Comp Update at the Don CeSar Hotel in Pete Beach, FL, will provide two days of vi …

Workers' Compensation Events

Social Media Links

WorkCompCentral Workers' Compensation
News and Education
4081 Mission Oaks Blvd
Camarillo, CA 93012
(805) 484-0333