Call or email us anytime
(805) 484-0333
Search Guide
Today is Monday, May 20, 2024 -

Industry Insights

Wong: Significant Board Decisions Refresher: Proper and Necessary Medical Treatment

  • State: Washington

This week’s refresher concerns significant Board of Industrial Insurance Appeals decisions related to medical treatment.

Sara Wong

Sara Wong

An injured worker shall receive “proper and necessary medical and surgical services” (Revised Code of Washington 51.36.010). Proper and necessary medical treatment is reflective of accepted standards of good practice and curative or rehabilitative, as further explained in Washington Administrative Code 296-20-01002.

Find out what the board has to say on proper and necessary medical treatment.

Significant decision No 1: In re Lyle Rilling, BIIA Dec., 88 4865 (1990)

  • Legal issue: Is further physical therapy proper and necessary medical treatment if a worker argues that physical therapy improves pain and functioning?
  • Key point: No, not in this case, where the facts showed that the worker’s condition was not temporary or transient (i.e., it was permanent) and that physical therapy would not provide fundamental or marked change.

Significant decision No. 2: In re Susan Pleas, BIIA Dec., 96 7931 (1998)

  • Legal issue: Are palliative and rehabilitative medical treatments mutually exclusive?
  • Key point: No, palliative and rehabilitative are not mutually exclusive terms. Medical treatment that is palliative may be approved so long as it is also rehabilitative (or curative). Treatment may be authorized if it is rehabilitative and reflective of accepted standards of good practice, thereby satisfying the requirements that it is “medically necessary” treatment within the meaning of WAC 296-20-01002 and “proper and necessary medical and surgical services” within the meaning of RCW 51.36.010.

Significant decision No. 3: In re Ladonia Skinner, BIIA Dec., 14 10594 (2015)

  • Legal issue: If a worker relies on the advice of his or her doctor and receives treatment recommended by the doctor, are the consequences from treatment covered under the claim?
  • Key point: Yes. If a worker reasonably relies on the advice of his or her doctor the consequences of treatment are compensable, even if the treatment later turns out to be ill-advised or not necessitated by a condition covered under the claim — unless the worker has been placed on notice that the treatment he or she wishes to pursue has been denied.

Significant decision No. 4: In re Paul Fish, BIIA Dec., 10 18494 (2011)

  • Legal issue: What impact do Department of Labor and Industries treatment guidelines have when determining whether a proposed treatment is proper and necessary?
  • Key point: Department guidelines in and of themselves do not provide a legal basis for the board to conclude whether treatment is proper and necessary. Rather, the board is required to make this determination based on medical testimony.

Significant decision No. 5: In re Zbiegniew Krawiec, BIIA Dec., 90 2281 (1991)

  • Legal issue: If a worker proceeds with an administratively denied surgery and the surgery is successful, can the board later consider the surgical results when determining if the administratively denied surgery was properly denied?
  • Key point: Yes. The board can consider a worker’s post-surgical status to retroactively determine whether an administratively denied surgery was properly denied.

Sara Wong is a litigation attorney in Reinisch Wilson Weier PC's Washington practice group for workers’ compensation defense. This column is republished with permission from the firm's website.

No Comments

Log in to post a comment


Do not post libelous remarks. You are solely responsible for the postings you input. By posting here you agree to hold harmless and indemnify WorkCompCentral for any damages and actions your post may cause.


Upcoming Events

  • May 22-23, 2024

    San Diego Elevate Workers' Com

    About #ELEVATEWORKCOMP This annual event is all about championing the cause to improve Workers’ C …

  • Jun 12-14, 2024

    20th Annual Conference: Legisl

    Registration Our signature event of the year annually draws a high-level audience of participants …

  • Jun 20-23, 2024

    California Applicants' Attorne

    Attendee Registration Opens Tuesday, April 9th @ 9:30 AM Sponsorships & Exhibitor Applications …

Workers' Compensation Events

Social Media Links

c/o Business Insurance Holdings, Inc.
PO Box 1010
Greenwich, CT 06836
(805) 484-0333