Switch back to WCC classic look
Our form filing service is undergoing maintenance and will be unavailable from 5 pm on 5/22 through 12 am on 5/26.
close [x]

WorkCompCentral – Workers' Compensation Education, Courses, News and Information

Call or email us anytime
(805) 484-0333
Search Guide
Today is Friday, May 22, 2015 -

Columns

N.Y. Treatment Guidelines: Investment Required for Return

  • State: New York
A report from the New York Workers' Compensation Alliance indicates that the application of medical treatment guidelines in the state has created an additional $60 million in costs for the workers' compensation system.  Let's place aside the fact that the source may be biased (the alliance "is a coalition of injured workers and other stakeholders committed to protecting the rights of injured workers") and assume the $60 million is a directionally correct number.

The report points out that the cost increase is due, in large part, to the application of the guidelines retrospectively.  As such, the Alliance argues, the state is now denying care it previously authorized and this is illogical and unfair.  I suppose it's somehow logical and fair to subject the care of newly injured workers to evidence-based medical treatment guidelines, but not apply those same standards of care to workers injured one year ago... or ten years ago.  I would argue that's patently unfair to workers injured prior to the adoption of the guidelines.  With new evidence comes new knowledge about treatments that work... and treatments that don't.  Why wouldn't we apply the best medical evidence we have to all claims involving ongoing medical treatment?  To do otherwise would create two different standards of care in New York.  (Personally, I would have liked to have seen a phased in approach - like Texas is using for the new closed formulary rules but New York chose not to do it that way.)

My view of the $60 million is that of an investment.  And I believe there will be return.

New York is experiencing the pain of establishing a new set of expectations for medical care delivery to work comp claimants.  This pain is political, cultural, and financial in nature.  But if the state will stick to its guns (and if the courts uphold the state's position), the return will come as providers adjust to the new treatment guidelines.  System costs will diminish as the clinical rationale necessary to secure a variance becomes clear to the provider community.

But perhaps the greatest return will come in form of improved health and function for injured workers.  This statement will be anathema to the Work Comp Alliance.  In fact, the report states "unlike medical treatment, which benefits the injured worker, the Medical Treatment Guidelines benefit no one in the workers’ compensation system."  This is unbelievably short-sighted and completely contrary to what we've learned about medicine over the past half century.  Not all medical treatment is good for the injured worker.

The right care at the right time delivered to the right patient by the right provider - that's the goal of evidence-based medicine.  That should be the goal of any work comp system.  And that's the recipe for providing value in the delivery of medical care to work comp claimants.

Michael Gavin is chief marketing officer for Prium, a utilization management company based in Duluth, Ga. This column was reprinted with his permission from the firm's Evidence Based blog.

No Comments

Log in to post a comment

Close




Do not post libelous remarks. You are solely responsible for the postings you input. By posting here you agree to hold harmless and indemnify WorkCompCentral for any damages and actions your post may cause.

Featured Subscription

Education Subscription Annual Pass

Did you know you can save a bundle on continuing education by purchasing our Education Subscription Annual Pass?

For just $509, you’ll get an entire year of continuing education with full access to WorkCompCentral’s library of online courses!

Your pass allows you:

  • Over 1,000 hours of CE courses
  • 400 CE hours added since 1/1/2012
  • Unlimited access 24/7/365
  • Includes LIVE seminars
NOTE: Certification and credential programs not included. Certain restrictions apply.

More details on our Education Subscription Annual Pass.

Subscribe TODAY!

Upcoming Events

  • May 28-31, 2015

    CWCDAA 2015 Summer Conference

    A great opportunity to earn MCLE credits in wonderful Las Vegas. Please check back for more inform …

  • May 31 – Jun 3, 2015

    National Council of Self Insur

    The 2015 annual meeting of the National Council of Self-Insurers will be at the Don CeSar Resort H …

  • Jun 1-2, 2015

    PA Dept. of Labor Annual Worke

    Experts in the field of workers' compensation, including representatives from the Bureau of Worker …

  • Jun 3, 2015

    MPN Trial Seminar

    Lee Siekerman with the Law Offices Of Peter Recchia in San Bernardino has 25 years of workers' c …