Switch back to WCC classic look
WCC's COVID-19 Information Collection
CMS Fails to Authorize Telemed for Physical Therapy, Leaving Reimbursement in Doubt close [x]

WorkCompCentral – Workers' Compensation Education, Courses, News and Information

Call or email us anytime
(805) 484-0333
Search Guide
Today is Monday, April 06, 2020 -

Industry Insights

Duff: Skeptical Ruminations on Walmart's Mass Workers' Compensation Settlements

  • National

I am not implacably opposed to all that is new. Indeed, I think we need a new, New Deal, and I am not so confident to claim that I know exactly what that should look like.

Michael C. Duff

Michael C. Duff

But I’m also a product of my experience. And as someone who has battled companies like Walmart in the trenches, while employed as a trial attorney with the National Labor Relations Board fighting for employees’ union organizing rights, I’m also not about to give certain actors the benefit of the doubt.

So when I see a story like the one I saw in WorkCompCentral recently about how Walmart has devised an efficient “mass settlement” program — a bunch of employees, judges (!!) and lawyers gathered in the same Walmart facility at the same time to settle cases — and how the company is “all in” on settling cases, I’m not going to lie: My first reaction was, “Uh oh.”

Nevertheless, the way I try to react to all new things I hear about is to apply simple cost-benefit analyses having an emphasis on the bottom-line benefit for working people. That is how I would have approached the original New Deal.

Want to sell me on the virtues of arbitration, workers’ compensation opt out, Walmart mass settlements, the gig economy or any other innovation? It’s simple: Just show me how working people are better off under the arrangement. Notice I didn’t say, “Just show me the change is pareto efficient.”

Imagine I have two marbles, and you have a mountain of marbles. Then we make a trade. Now I have three marbles and you have an even bigger mountain of marbles. That trade was pareto efficient: Someone (in this case both transacting parties) was made better off, and no one was made worse off.

But did I mention that at the time we made the trade I was in dire poverty and that the trade did nothing meaningful to alleviate my poverty? When pareto efficient, wheeling and dealing (aka innovation coupled with economic rent-seeking) is made in a pre-existing context of social contract erosion, it is hard to see how something good has happened.

These days, I have become aware that it is increasingly rare for the economically powerful to even attempt to demonstrate why their schemes are better for ordinary people. I’m constantly telling people that my late dad was the type of Republican who would try to demonstrate how his viewpoint would actually be better for ordinary people.

I always respected him for that quality. And even though we frequently disagreed, I thought that if he and I were in a room for long enough we might actually be able to come up with something workable (temporarily, at least).

So, my bottom line on Walmart mass settlements is this: Show me how much injured workers are receiving in these settlements, and describe for me the process under which the deliberations are carried out.

Transparency is everything. If you won’t show me, I don’t believe you. Or to put it in lawyer-speak, I will draw an adverse inference and assume the arrangement will be worse for working people, not better.

Michael C. Duff is associate dean for student programs and external relations, and is professor of law, at the University of Wyoming College of Law. This entry is republished from the Workers' Compensation Law Professors blog, with permission.

No Comments

Log in to post a comment


Do not post libelous remarks. You are solely responsible for the postings you input. By posting here you agree to hold harmless and indemnify WorkCompCentral for any damages and actions your post may cause.

Featured Video

Upcoming Events

  • Apr 10, 2020

    FACTS not FEAR: COVID-19

    National Workers Compensation Industry Experts share latest updates, best practices, recommendati …

  • Apr 13-16, 2020

    RX Drug Abuse & Heroin Summit

    *Postponed In the wake of the latest CDC guidance around the COVID-19 pandemic and after deliberat …

  • Apr 15, 2020

    Preventing Workplace Violence:

    Nearly two million Americans experience violence in the workplace annually. According to the Natio …

Workers' Compensation Events

Social Media Links

WorkCompCentral Workers' Compensation
News and Education
4081 Mission Oaks Blvd
Camarillo, CA 93012
(805) 484-0333