That utilization review physicians do not owe a duty of care to injured workers can reasonably be deduced from the recent California Supreme Court decision that trashed Kirk King's tort claim over an incorrect and harmful UR decision.
In a nutshell, King sustained back injury in 2008 that led to chronic pain associated with depression. Klonopin was prescribed by his treating physicians, who interviewed and examined him. He did well on this medicine for two years.
That's when Dr. Naresh Sharma decided without interviewing or examining the patient that the klonopin was not medically necessary. The hitherto authorized medication was then summarily discontinued. The sudden withdrawal of medication led to King's having four seizures.
King and family asserted that Sharma and his utilization review organization employer had acted negligently, and since Sharma was working for the URO known as CompPartners, both deserved to be disciplined and sued.
Not so, said the court. Hiding behind the mantle of law, the justices totally ignored the patient's plight. Their ruling side-stepped the tort issue and said instead that the exclusive remedy for this type of dispute is entirely within the purview of the utilization review process.
Too bad for King. All the better for the corporate interests, and the employers that control and operate UROs.
On the other hand, the court noted that the utilization review process may not be working as it should — an open invitation for new legislation.
Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuellar was quoted in WorkCompCentral by Greg Jones as saying that protections for injured workers "may not be set at optimal levels and the Legislature may find it makes sense to change them" -— another open invitation for new legislation to revisit the authority of utilization reviewers and their UROs.
Changes should be introduced for legislation in 2019.
Using gut-and-amend techniques as mentioned in our previous column on Senate Bill 790 is one way these changes can be made. We would, of course, expect employers to suffer their own seizures at the thought of it.
Here's our big five of recommended changes:
Dr. Robert Weinmann writes the Politics of Healthcare blog, from which this entry was taken with permission.
May 13-15, 2024
Join us May 13–15, 2024, for NCCI's Annual Insights Symposium (AIS) 2024, the industry’s premier e …
May 13-14, 2024
The Board of Managers is excited to announce that the CSIA 2024 Annual Meeting and Educational Con …
May 22-23, 2024
About #ELEVATEWORKCOMP This annual event is all about championing the cause to improve Workers’ C …
No Comments
Log in to post a comment