Call or email us anytime
(805) 484-0333
Search Guide
Today is Sunday, April 11, 2021 -

Industry Insights

Duff: A Disguised Vaccination Mandate

  • State: Illinois

A workers’ compensation bill filed in the Illinois House on Friday provides that “no compensation shall be awarded to a claimant for death or disability arising out of an exposure to COVID-19 if the employee has refused a vaccination.”

Michael C. Duff

Michael C. Duff

This is a very sticky wicket. If the state may compel an individual to receive a vaccine, despite Fourth Amendment considerations, then perhaps the provision is no big deal (even though it leaves a bad taste in my mouth).

But if the state cannot compel receipt of the vaccine, then I am at a loss to say how the provision does not amount to a prohibited conditioned benefit — one conditioned on foregoing a constitutional right (see Perry v. Sinderman, Sherbert v. Verner).

Indeed, I think workers’ compensation benefits implicate this principle even more strongly than the cases I cited, which essentially stood for the principle that, even if the creation of a right by the government (such as, say, a welfare benefit) is completely discretionary, the benefit may not be freighted with unconstitutional conditions: “You get this benefit only if you agree never to belong to any faith other than Christianity.”

But in the case of workers’ compensation, the quid pro quo for a tort right, I resist the notion that the “benefit” received is completely discretionary. It is not a welfare benefit; it is a substitute for a historically conferred tort remedy of ancient lineage. So the state can take that benefit from me unless I assent to an unconstitutional invasion of my body?

As I say, if a mandatory vaccination is not an unconstitutional invasion of my body, then my concern fades into the mist. In any event, it is a very unsavory way for the state to sneak into the law a vaccination mandate. If it is to be done, do it in the open.

Michael C. Duff is associate dean for student programs and external relations, and is professor of law, at the University of Wyoming College of Law. This entry is republished from the Workers' Compensation Law Professors blog, with permission.

No Comments

Log in to post a comment


Do not post libelous remarks. You are solely responsible for the postings you input. By posting here you agree to hold harmless and indemnify WorkCompCentral for any damages and actions your post may cause.

Featured Video

Upcoming Events

  • Apr 14, 2021

    NAIRO 2021 Symposium

    Each year, NAIRO and its member companies stage an annual Symposium discussing the latest developm …

  • Apr 17, 2021

    Featured Webinar: 2021 Annual

    Overview: This program offers expert instruction and advice on rating, while providing the student …

  • Apr 20-29, 2021

    The IAIABC Forum 2021

    About the IAIABC Forum 2021 The focus of The Forum is collaboration. At The Forum, the IAIABC's c …

Workers' Compensation Events

Social Media Links

WorkCompCentral Workers' Compensation
News and Education
PO Box 1010
Greenwich, CT 06836
(805) 484-0333